• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • Canada

Sorry has been the hardest word for governments

3 years ago

Legalized betting apps coming to NY, but experts wonder if this is the right approach

1 hour ago

Boy, 12, shot walking on a Brooklyn street

1 hour ago
ADVERTISEMENT

SEE IT: Motorcycle-riding duo rips chain from woman’s neck in Manhattan

2 hours ago

RCMP suspend search overnight for 5-year-old boy missing near Old Man River

2 hours ago

Councillor suggests Calgary try allowing alcohol consumption in city parks

2 hours ago

RCMP investigate child's death at motel in Duncan, B.C.

3 hours ago

Rescheduled Dubai Expo hopes to attract 25 million visits

4 hours ago

Mexico’s President to finally take the vaccine

2 days ago

Ontario declares stay at home order

2 days ago

Cellular service is expanding in Vancouver Island

3 days ago

Cellular service is expanding in Vancouver Island

3 days ago

B.C. breaks COVID19 case numbers with back to back Reporting of new cases

1 week ago
WNews
  • Go
  • W-World Media Inc.
    • W-World Films
  • ABOUT US
  • CONTACT
Saturday, April 10, 2021
5 °c
Vancouver
5 ° Sun
7 ° Mon
9 ° Tue
10 ° Wed
  • Login
  • COVID19Hot
  • World
  • Canada
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Tech
  • Science
  • Showbiz
No Result
View All Result
WNews
  • COVID19Hot
  • World
  • Canada
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Tech
  • Science
  • Showbiz
No Result
View All Result
WNews
No Result
View All Result

Sorry has been the hardest word for governments

by evan dyer
November 29, 2017
in Politics
Reading Time: 6 mins read
0 0
A A
0
Home Politics
ADVERTISEMENT
0
SHARES
1
VIEWS
Share on Facebook

Canada’s next official apology is already in the works.

The country, through its prime minister, is expected to express contrition for the historic cruelty of turning away the St. Louis, a ship carrying Jewish refugees fleeing Nazism in 1939.

The passengers had already been refused entry by Cuban and U.S. authorities. Rejected and dejected, they would return to a Europe on the brink of war. Many would die in Nazi concentration camps.

A statement of regret, 80 years after the fact, will fit firmly into the Canadian government’s record of official apology.

Until Tuesday’s LGBTQ2 apology — and leaving aside apologies to individuals such as Maher Arar — Canada had atoned for three types of wrongs: those related to the Indian Residential School system, wrongs related to immigration, such as the Chinese head tax or the Komagata Maru incident, and wrongs it perpetrated during the two world wars, such as the internment of Japanese-Canadians and the executions of Canadian soldiers during the First World War.

RelatedPosts

Legalized betting apps coming to NY, but experts wonder if this is the right approach

Boy, 12, shot walking on a Brooklyn street

SEE IT: Motorcycle-riding duo rips chain from woman’s neck in Manhattan

The St. Louis incident checks two of those three boxes.

Some in the Jewish community have fought for years to make the government acknowledge that its decision was heartless and tainted by anti-Semitism.

The German Girl - Book

Jewish refugees aboard the MS St. Louis attempt to communicate with friends and relatives in Cuba, June 3, 1939. The ship’s passengers were later refused entry to Canada and many died in the Holocaust. (United States Holocaust Memorial Museum/National Archives and Records)

Others are less keen. Sally Zerker, whose Polish-Jewish family members on the St. Louis were turned away, wrote in Canadian Jewish News that an apology now would be “nothing but a shallow, empty, meaningless act.”

“It will not bring back my relatives, or offer me any solace. Instead, it will whitewash a government that did nothing to help the Jews who were fleeing the Nazis and ignored the type of anti-Semitism that was endemic in Canada until the 1970s.”

But Zerker’s reaction is not typical. Though panned by some critics as “virtue-signalling” and gesture politics, apologies often mean a lot to the people to whom they’re directed.

Apologies, left and right

It was Conservative Brian Mulroney who broke the ice in 1988, when he apologized for the internment of Japanese-Canadians (Ronald Reagan the same year signed a similar apology to Japanese-Americans who were interned). Stephen Harper followed suit in 2006 with an apology for the head tax that unfairly penalized Chinese immigrants from 1885 to 1923.

Harper also made what is probably Canada’s biggest apology to date for the residential school system. Justin Trudeau’s apology last week extended that apology to residential school survivors in Newfoundland and Labrador who had been excluded.

Stephen Harper apologized to victims of the residential school victims

Then prime minister Stephen Harper shakes hands with Indigenous leaders on June 11, 2008, the day he formally apologized on behalf of the Canadian government for the residential school system. The exclusion of schools in Newfoundland and Labrador led to another apology by Justin Trudeau last week. (Fred Chartrand/Canadian Press)

Trudeau’s own father was no fan of saying sorry. When Mulroney first proposed an apology for Japanese-Canadians in 1984, Trudeau rebuffed him.

“I do not think it is the purpose of a government to right the past,” Pierre Trudeau said. “It is our purpose to be just in our time.”

“My father might have a different perspective on it than I do,” Justin Trudeau said Monday, as he prepared to apologize for the persecution of LGBT Canadians.

“He came at it as an academic, as a constitutionalist. I come at it as a teacher, as someone who’s worked a lot in communities.”

Lawyers hate apologies

Trudeau could also have said his father came at it as a lawyer, which he was.

Lawyers routinely tell their clients that apologies can be construed as admissions of guilt or liability — and can carry a price tag.

Concerns about reparations long delayed an official U.S. government apology for slavery.

Former U.S. president Bill Clinton condemned his country’s record on a visit to Senegal in 1998, but added the caveat: “We cannot push time backward through the door of no return. We have lived our history.”

Ten years would pass before the U.S. Congress would pass a resolution apologizing for more than 200 years of slavery and segregation of African-Americans.

But the Senate’s beautifully worded apology to African-Americans ends with this rather jarring clause: “Disclaimer: Nothing in this resolution  a) authorizes or supports any claim against the United States; or b) serves as a settlement of any claim against the United States.”

Limited liability

Slavery began in United States during colonial times, but it persisted long after the U.S. Declaration of Independence, as the Congressional apology acknowledged.

Should Canada’s responsibility for historic wrongs extend to pre-Confederation times?

Stephen Harper thought not, which is why he excluded Newfoundland and Labrador from his residential school apology in 2008. Trudeau has decided that the province’s pre-Confederation history (N.L. joined in 1949) was Canada’s history. And it’s a history with its own set of wrongs.

Relations between Newfoundland’s original inhabitants, the Beothuks, and its settlers were so bad that encounters between the two usually left one side dead. The last confirmed member of the Beothuk people died in 1829.

And the same British Crown that pacified Quebec by extending legal tolerance and equality to its Catholic majority showed a much harsher face in its Newfoundland colony. There, it imposed the same code of discrimination and persecution it operated in Ireland: the Penal Laws.

The policies enacted in a forlorn bid to prevent Irish people from settling Newfoundland included banning the Roman Catholic religion, hunting priests and nuns, burning homes and outbuildings and refusing the right of burial.

Official government correspondence of the era typically refers to the island’s Irish people as “idle, disorderly, useless men and women” and “disaffected, disloyal, disorderly, enured to drunkenness, debauchery, vices and felonies of all kinds.”

Irish people lived under absurd restrictions — for example, no two “Papist” men could spend the winter under the same roof unless they were servants of a Protestant master — and any infraction was an excuse for exile.

Sins of the Crown

Acadian family members place flowers at the base of a monument honouring the memory of Acadians who were deported 250 years ago, on the waterfront in Halifax in 2005. (Andrew Vaughan/Canadian Press)

At least one of Canada’s pre-Confederation wrongs has already been addressed in a formal apology — from the Queen.

The expulsion of the Acadians in 1755 from what is now the Maritimes and Quebec was a historic transgression whose consequences are still felt by the exiles’ descendants (some of whom live in Louisiana rather than Nova Scotia, for one thing).

Queen Elizabeth apologized to the Acadians in 2003, signing a royal “Proclamation Designating 28 July of Every Year as A Day of Commemoration of the Great Upheaval.”

But she was careful to add a rider:

“Our present proclamation does not, under any circumstances, constitute a recognition of legal or financial responsibility by the Crown.”

This story was published on CBC News. For the rest of the story please read the story right here http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/government-apologies-responsibility-1.4423371?cmp=rss.

 

This post was originally published on this site

Get real time update about this post categories directly on your device, subscribe now.

Unsubscribe
Previous Post

Highway 7 shut down east of Agassiz, B.C. after collision

Next Post

Ontario working to ban eye tattoos after mishap

evan dyer

evan dyer

Related Posts

Researcher says coronavirus variants could require annual vaccinations, like the flu

April 3, 2021
4

CBC Radio's The House: Lock down, open up, repeat

April 3, 2021
8

Meet the Canadian millenial running to lead the United Nations

April 2, 2021
2

Did the political art of compromise fail Canada during the pandemic?

April 2, 2021
2

B.C. biotech company says, despite interim approval, provinces won't use its COVID-19 treatment

April 1, 2021
8

Nearly 15% of adult Canadians have received one dose of a vaccine: PHAC

April 1, 2021
4
Next Post

Ontario working to ban eye tattoos after mishap

Popular

  • BREAKING: Police Activity After Langley Bank Robbery

    16 shares
    Share 16 Tweet 0
  • Barrie nurse fired for using fentanyl at work gets chance at reinstatement

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Update: Langley Church Held Services Defying Public Health Orders, 2nd Week in a Row

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • One Person Dead after Multiple people stabbed at North Vancouver Library, Suspect in custody, police say

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • NYT: US ramps up cyber attacks on Russia

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Weather

Vancouver, Canada
Saturday, April 10, 2021
Clear
5 ° c
67%
9.94mh
-%
9 c 0 c
Sun
13 c 1 c
Mon
15 c 3 c
Tue
16 c 4 c
Wed
  • #WNNTrending:
  • Donald Trump
  • North Korea
  • #BlueMonday
  • #MLKJDay
  • #January20
  • #Apple
  • About Us
  • WNews Beta Program
  • Editions
  • Version History
  • Term of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • WNewsNetwork Comment Rules
  • Community Standards
  • About Us
  • WNews Beta Program
  • Editions
  • Version History
  • Term of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • WNewsNetwork Comment Rules
  • Community Standards

©2014-2021 | WNewsNetwork, A W-World Brand. All Rights Reserved. | WNews nor W-World is responsible for external links. User discretion is advised.

  • Login
  • Cart
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • 2020 In Review
  • COVID-19 Pandemic
  • World
    • USA
  • Latest News
    • Politics
    • Opinions
    • Technology
      • Apple
      • Google
  • Canada
    • BC
  • Lifestyle
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Travel
  • Reviews
    • Movies
    • Music
    • TV
    • TV & Streaming Boxes
  • Sports
    • Football
    • Hockey
    • Soccer
  • Trending Now
    • Top5
    • #WNNBreaking
  • Business
    • Finance
    • Education/Family

©2014-2021 | WNewsNetwork, A W-World Brand. All Rights Reserved. | WNews nor W-World is responsible for external links. User discretion is advised.

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?